Comic Carnival

307 reviews

7235 N Keystone Ave suite e, Indianapolis, IN 46240

comiccarnival.com

+13172538882

About

Comic Carnival is a Comic book store located at 7235 N Keystone Ave suite e, Indianapolis, IN 46240. It has received 307 reviews with an average rating of 4.7 stars.

Photos

Hours

Monday10AM-8PM
Tuesday12-5PM
Wednesday11AM-8PM
Thursday11AM-8PM
Friday11AM-8PM
Saturday11AM-8PM
Sunday11AM-8PM

F.A.Q

Frequently Asked Questions

  • The address of Comic Carnival: 7235 N Keystone Ave suite e, Indianapolis, IN 46240

  • Comic Carnival has 4.7 stars from 307 reviews

  • Comic book store

  • "Walked in, went to the counter to buy somethimg and the guy behind the counter couldn't even be bothered"

    "I am from Gary, Indiana and I came down this way so my wife could go to a bridal shower"

    "Comic Carnival is one of the best comic stores in Indy"

    "Bought some cool dice from here for my DND campaign and some Pokémon cards"

    "Been going for 30yrs It has the best selection of back issues in the City! Love the New store just 4-5 doors down from the the old store location! The New store is BIGGER Lots of Space ! EVEN MORE Back Issues ,TPB ,Card Games! If you like the store B4 you'll Love it more now, and won't want to leave!"

Reviews

  • J.M. Day

Walked in, went to the counter to buy somethimg and the guy behind the counter couldn't even be bothered. If there were other employees present, they were focused on playing around and let momey walk right out the door. I've spent a few dollars here in the past but I won't be coming back after this. Tcgplayer it is from now on.

  • David Kendall

I am from Gary, Indiana and I came down this way so my wife could go to a bridal shower. I was not allowed there so I googled local comic shops. This place is one of the better places I went to. The younger guy at the counter was very nice and helpful. The place has a good selection of back issues. Highly recommend this place.

  • Wayne Whited

Comic Carnival is one of the best comic stores in Indy. Great selection of back issues, both modern and collectors, and they keep most new issues in stock so you can always find the issues you want. Plus, the staff is very friendly and helpful. I come from out of the area, but always try to stop when I'm in the Indy area.

  • Ally Bright

Bought some cool dice from here for my DND campaign and some Pokémon cards. All at great prices. The store is fun to walk around. The staff is very nice and kind. They chatted with us and made sure we got any help we needed finding items. Would highly recommend this store for your comic book and nerdy needs!

  • James Thomas

Been going for 30yrs It has the best selection of back issues in the City! Love the New store just 4-5 doors down from the the old store location! The New store is BIGGER Lots of Space ! EVEN MORE Back Issues ,TPB ,Card Games! If you like the store B4 you'll Love it more now, and won't want to leave!

  • Cloris PatientC

This comic store is a rare one, in terms of accessibility. The aisles are wide enough for canes, walkers and wheelchairs. Although they have high shelves, they are happy to help get you anything you want to see. As for stock, they have all the current goodies and will order anything else. Enjoy!

  • Jerry Velasco

For the size, this place has a good mixture of gaming products. Its main focus is comics obviously. Its always stocked with new products. The staff is very helpful and family friendly. I would recommend this store. The location is perfectly snug between downtown and Carmel.

  • Bo

My favorite comic book store in the entire state. They have an extremely knowledgeable and friendly staff. The store is very clean and organized. They have a huge selection of back issues along with plenty of new stuff too. You won't be disappointed with this store.

  • Cathair Apocalypse

Huge store with a great selection of vintage and new titles, mainstream and indies. The gaming tables are open till 8/9 most nights and the staff creates an awesome atmosphere you can spend hours here. Affordable prices. And YES they have Cathair Apocalypse!

  • Jacob Ott

This is one of the best comic shop I’ve ever used. I think Comics Carnival is one of the oldest comic retailers in the entire Midwest and it shows. The staff behind the counter have great recommendations. They don’t just sell comics, cards,

  • Truck Drivin' Kid Billy

This is a pretty average comic book store as of lately because a lot of them have become commercialized…. When I walked in someone did say hello but then continue talking to their coworker as I walked in and didn’t even really know where to

  • Nicholas P.

We stop by here anytime we visit the Walmart nearby. Staff here are some of the most informative and friendly folks I've ever met. Great selection of comics. They're supportive of several local publications. Board game selection is small,

  • Gary Brumitt

Best comic shop in central Indiana. I switched to this shop from the previous one I had been going to because...well, I thought the customer service was grossly lacking at my old place. Smart decision. The folks here are great. Everyone

  • Matthew Wilson

I have been a customer here since 2009. You can not find a better comic book store in my opinion. They know me by name and are always willing to order me things of they don't have them. They have games on the weekends and the staff and

  • lampwire

This establishment is weight bearing pillar of the comic book industry in Indianapolis. The staff here is extremely friendly and knowledgeable, the selection of items (TPBs, new comics, back issues, toys and games) is vast, pricing is

  • Tim Hunt

Pretty good store. Lots of reasonably priced back issues and magazines. The only reason I take off one star is that they had all of their high-priced books in boxes behind the counter and I couldn't just peruse through them to see if

  • Fatimah Al-Ansari

This shop is AMAZING. I’ve been looking for the Loki Agents of Asgard’s forever. They had ALL 3 of the collections for their original price. The only places I could find them we’re on eBay for over a $100. They also had an extensive

  • Lucas Mitchell

This is my go to comic shop! I use to shop at other comic shops around town and none of them compare to how well this shop is to me! Friendly staff always fun to chat with. I always look forward to pick up my comics here every week!

  • Noelle Huffman

By far the best shop in the city (and probably state) for vintage back issues. Don’t forget to ask to see the boxes kept behind the counter (everything over $10, underground/indie, etc.). They also always have the best new comic

  • Jeremy “JD” Hess

The owner is a very nice gentleman who is very knowledgeable about all things comics. The store has a great selection of old and new comics, action figures, pops, board games, Heroclix and other cool geeky collectibles.

  • Matthew Graphman

It's been years since I've been in a Comic Carnival. They have a great selection of back issues as well as current titles. The staff are very helpful as well. Plus they stay open late on Fridays.

  • S G

Great comic shop! First timers or old skool, new releases or back issues. They have got it! Super friendly staff. Shout out to my man Kaleb! He is awesome cool young guy who will help you out!

  • Shelby Kissick

Pricey, but we enjoyed our trip still. The staff was friendly and very helpful in helping us find comics for a lower elementary age kid. There were quite a few options for the 6-10 age range!

  • Annalise Hartley

Excellent comic selection with a really nice staff. They almost always have recent issues that I’m looking for and a really good selection of variant covers, back issues, and trades.

  • KillerKitty0330

This is an awesome comic book store very nice selection of comics old and new the owner Is awesome very nice guy me and my husband will be going back when we visit Indiana again!

  • Robin Lance

I went here searching for DnD items, and tbh they didn't have much... But, they had a great selection of comics. Plus, the guy working the store was

  • GS MA

I was on a road trip and randomly stopped in. Pretty cool. Nice back issue selection and others behind the counter. Good service too.

  • Venomous Beetle

Best in Indiana, best in world (that I've been to) The decor as well as the selection has always impressed me even before they

  • Lonnie Sapp

Fantastic comic book store on the north side of Indianapolis! Lots of boxes of back issues and great to do business with.

  • TheSeeingKarp

helpful staff. They always are ready to talk to customers and help them find what they are looking for. Very inviting

  • Rebecca Hall

A ton of comic book variety! A few board games, but mainly comic books. Staff were kind and helpful.

  • Matt

Aesthetically it's one of the best comic shops you will see. Like back issues? They have TONS

  • Kentucky Keys

Nice selection and friendly staff. No military discount like most shops offer. …

  • P.D. Anderson

A great selection of back issues and all the new books you need for your collection.

  • Victor

Great place and great selection. Very friendly staff 10 out of 10 would recommend.

  • geodude2387 pokemon go

Bought a starwars funko pop here owner was super nice highly recommend this place

  • Michael Duckett

Coolest place as a child coolest place as adult Comic carnival rules

  • Zachary Flajs

Great selection and help! Had exactly what I was after.

  • Jeff K

Great staff. We'll knowledged and extremely helpful

  • Daniel Hartzler

Friendly and helpful staff. Great selection

Similar places

Comic Book University

854 reviews

7623 Shelby St, Indianapolis, IN 46227

Downtown Comics

279 reviews

11 E Market St, Indianapolis, IN 46204

Downtown Comics In Castleton

222 reviews

5767 E 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46250

Comics Elite

181 reviews

5575 Elmwood Ave E2, Indianapolis, IN 46203

The Hero House

127 reviews

1112 Prospect St, Indianapolis, IN 46203

The Bunker Comics & Gaming

115 reviews

5305 W 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46268

Prideland Comics & Collectibles LLC

38 reviews

5668 Crawfordsville Rd Suite D, Speedway, IN 46224

Raven's Comics, Collectibles & Books

36 reviews

2016 E Southport Rd #1, Indianapolis, IN 46227

BLRD GXNG PRODUCTIONS LLC

9165 Otis Ave #270, Indianapolis, IN 46216