Policygenius

1116 reviews

32 Old Slip Suite 500, New York, NY 10005

www.policygenius.com

+18556952255

About

Policygenius is a Insurance agency located at 32 Old Slip Suite 500, New York, NY 10005. It has received 1116 reviews with an average rating of 4.6 stars.

Photos

Hours

Monday9AM-10PM
Tuesday9AM-8PM
Wednesday9AM-8PM
Thursday9AM-8PM
Friday9AM-10PM
Saturday9AM-10PM
Sunday9AM-10PM

F.A.Q

Frequently Asked Questions

  • The address of Policygenius: 32 Old Slip Suite 500, New York, NY 10005

  • Policygenius has 4.6 stars from 1116 reviews

  • Insurance agency

  • "Horrible experience"

    "My wife and I were looking to renew our life insurance policies"

    "The people I encountered were genuinely concerned with providing a quality service at an affordable price, which for me was very important"

    "Applying for insurance is a pain but the pg team was really helpful and had real, actual people who were in the customer service part that were attached to my case and would follow up with me"

    "If you don’t know where to start or feel overwhelmed thinking about the details that come with choosing life insurance, policy genius is as easy as it gets"

Reviews

  • Brian Apostolon

Horrible experience. I started an application for Life Insurance over 4 weeks ago. The plan I was trying to get was a one that didn’t make you prove health. But the company asked me a host of health related questions anyway so I obliged and answered them honestly. About a week go by and now they want all my medical records from my primary care. The problem with that is he is no longer at the medical group that I used any longer. They have been bought out (compass medical) and the doctor is now at a new group and was not able to take with him any of the patients medical records. I tried getting them but wasn’t able to. I did provide them with the lab report of my latest blood work as well as access to my therapist that prescribes 2 different meds to me but that wasn’t good enough. I get a call today by a rep from policy genius saying there is nothing they can do, I would simply have to re apply for a policy that WILL make me prove health. This is very misleading and disappointing. Not to mention a huge waste of my time for 5 weeks now. This Policy Genius is a bunch of amateurs and provided me with horrible service and mislead me. Go elsewhere. Trust me.

  • Patrick Fell

My wife and I were looking to renew our life insurance policies. Our financial advisors both recommended Protective Life. Both of us were declined without any conversation. I reached out to Policy Genius and Stephanie was fantastic. She helped me through the process and I have secured a policy at a preferred rate. She is working to help my wife get a policy as well. I'm very grateful to her for her incredible customer service and finding the best companies for my wife and I.

  • Everett Yancey

The people I encountered were genuinely concerned with providing a quality service at an affordable price, which for me was very important. But, beyond that, I felt at ease and in no way hassled or felt forced in any way. I can now rest in the knowledge that when the time comes, I have secured some form of financial freedom in my loved one's time of need. Thank you. Everett l

  • nora wolf

Applying for insurance is a pain but the pg team was really helpful and had real, actual people who were in the customer service part that were attached to my case and would follow up with me. The service was basically unparalleled. I was truly impressed. They made something that could have been a drag into something that was way less painful.

  • Shireen Griffith

If you don’t know where to start or feel overwhelmed thinking about the details that come with choosing life insurance, policy genius is as easy as it gets. They help you choose the policy you can afford and one that fits your needs. Customer service is excellent and premiums are so affordable it’ll be easy to pay them yearly if you wish.

  • Deb Antonetti

I am very happy. Everything was handled promptly and professionally from the very start. Application was easy to complete and the quotes were received the next day. The associate who helped with my call, Ashley Taylor, was knowledgeable and professional, as well as very personable

  • Linda Roberts

Policygenius took the time to get me insured with the right agency for an affordable price. Afterwards I received a follow up call from the original agent that I spoke with to see if I received a call to complete my application. I Thought that was very considerate of her. Linda

  • Justin Salley

They made the process so easy and so fast. I had coverage in just a couple of days after the initial 30 minute phone call. They were super helpful and clear when explaining things to me and I never felt pressured to buy anything I didn't want. I wish I'd done this sooner

  • LaTonya Payne

Process was smooth. The representative was very friendly and made the experience an enjoyable one. She explained everything, told me all of my options and helped me thru the process beginning to end.I now have life insurance and peace of mind. Thank you Policy Genius!!

  • Whitney Stutz

They were extremely helpful. The process of getting term life insurance was fun as they were able to find me a policy that fit my needs, walk me through the application. Was able to get approved by the end of the phone call. Thank you so much.

  • Dylan T

Policygenius was a 5 star from the moment I input my general inquiry. They were quick to respond to my request to set up an appointment on my time line; the rep was 100% transparent on how they are compenstated; gathered multiple quotes for

  • J.D.

Policygenius is very similar to SelectQuote and Zander. Unlike Zander, Policygenius quoted me the cheaper policy and it didn't require a medical exam. Overall, the process was simple to navigate, and Policygenius quickly answered all of my

  • Patrick Miller

I got a quick Accurate friendly service from policy genius.I got quick estimates forAutomobile and homeowner policies and was able to select homeowner policy that met my needs. the quotes forAuto insurance were higher than what I am paying

  • james wimbush

PolicyGenius was with me all the way if it wasn't for the staff they have I don't think I would have this coverage my Dr. wasn't corporateing was having problems with my phone I was about to give up but they didn't they was and are willing

  • Matthew Evans

Shopped home insurance with them and got a good quote started policy and what canceled from under writer. Policygenius can’t do anything to help seems like a huge scam. Guess they are only the middle men for the insurance companies but I

  • Ron Nov

In 6/2021 became a customer and at that time things were fine but now the lack of professionalism is beyond frustrating. The fact is that right now this company has no respect for their client's time I have sent emails through their

  • Josiah Travis

My experience with Policygenious was great. Getting a new policy was easy and the rates they provided beat competitors. The people I interacted with were courteous and helpful. The whole process was finished in a few days.

  • Ryan Blumenstein

Policygenius made it easy to get information about policy options and find new coverage that saved me about $400/year. The agent I worked with was very responsive and helpful without being pushy.

  • Eric Norful

I shopped several "Online Insurance" quote brokers and Policygenius ended up be the cheapest by far. They were quick with providing quotes and easy to use. I recommend them for sure.

  • Ai Lian

The process was easy and fast. The agent that worked with me was very professional and helpful. I was able to get the insurance I need with a very reasonable price.

Similar places

National General Insurance

2818 reviews

59 Maiden Ln, New York, NY 10038

Rhino

2566 reviews

99 Wall St, New York, NY 10005

Steve Fay - State Farm Insurance Agent

1685 reviews

6608 18th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11204

Jose Rivera - State Farm Insurance Agent

1213 reviews

169-22 Jamaica Ave, Queens, NY 11432

Hielly Martinez - State Farm Insurance Agent

901 reviews

251 E 138th St, Bronx, NY 10451

Kenny Vega - State Farm Insurance Agent

719 reviews

49-06 Queens Blvd, Woodside, NY 11377

Kenny Vega - State Farm Insurance Agent

718 reviews

39-20 Queens Blvd, Queens, NY 11104

Jewelz Santiago - State Farm Insurance Agent

717 reviews

3657 Broadway Frnt 2, New York, NY 10031

Sammy Martinez - State Farm Insurance Agent

691 reviews

2116 86th St, Brooklyn, NY 11214

LJ Insurance Agency Inc

675 reviews

127-03 Rockaway Blvd, Queens, NY 11420