They have a friendly and comfortable atmosphere and while they don't have a large selection of cigars, they do have a decent variety of the brands they carry. They also have several tap beers to choose from and pool tables to enjoy while you're there. I had a pretty good time hanging out and talking with other patrons.

Perfect when you want to get away!! Sit in a comfy lounge chair, smoke a cigar and catch a local artist performing on stage. Get done with you cigar head to the pool table area. Even if there isn't a local performer on the set list the music is extremely enjoyable to add to the pleasant vibe of the staff. More

Literally love this place they have pool tables great drinks and a full selection of cigars to suite your taste but overall the service is amazing and the vibe is very welcoming our bartender Alex was honestly the best bartender ever ,make sure to go see her!!!

This is a Quant little bar with alot of class to it and all the Bartenders are Awesome everyone should stop in for a glass of win,shot or just an ice cold beer good times and good memories,they are still the best place in Mayport to hang out …

Good place to grab a cigar, watch some TV, chat with people and play some pool. It was clean, including the restroom. They have 2 humidors. The large walk in one has your traditional cigars. Wide selection even their very own Island Girl by

I came in primarily for a cigar and possibly a few drinks. Unfortunately after some search on my own including using the light on my own to see into one of the humidors, I discovered they were out of both cigars I was looking for. Since

Love this place, wish it was here when I use to live right around the corner. Aaron was super awesome, helpful, and friendly. Ideal place to hangout and have a smoke and a drink. I'll miss this location, till next time island girl.

After several years of coming here we will never be back. Sat at the bar for 15 minutes and was ignored by both bartenders. I expect better out of Isalnd Girl wether Bob is full owner or not. Nothing more than a Mayport dive bar

Our new happy hour spot! Great staff, beautiful bar, games, & of course refreshing beverages. I'm a non smoker & expected a strong cigar, smoky haze, but nada. I come home smelling as smoke free as ever.

I can’t say enough good things about this place - cigars, drinks and pool..you can’t lose. Carly and staff make this place feel like home and she runs a great ship - check them out if you like having fun

Great place to meet coworkers and friends to have a well made drink with a large collection of cigars/ tap beer. Bar tenders are a great group of people. Love them all. HAPPY Hour

Not my side of town but glad I found this place with the wife. Carly was awesome even when she was thawing ice out. 10 of 10 will return again.

Very nice. I enjoyed myself. Worth a stop if you're looking for a place to drink and also smoke. When I'm out this way I will visit again.

The atmosphere was fantastic and the 2 lady's serving were beyond helpful. Will be coming back without a doubt next time I'm in the area.

Awesome cigar lounge. The staff are great. The new pool room is a must and looks great. All these reasons give it a five star from me.

Most Island Girl cigar bars are very good, not This one. Limited selection of cigars and not a good place to sit and smoke

Great cigar selection, lots of good brews on tap. Comfy lounge atmosphere. Fantastic service!!!! Love this place!!!

The WATER on draft Triple distilled, reverse obi wan kenobi Marble countertops smooth as a baby’s bottom

Pretty cool little place. Smallish humador compared to the other places. But a nice selection of beers. More

What an Awesome Cigar Lounge! The Smoked Old Fashioned and Coffee Was Spot On! Had a ROCK STAR BARTENDER!

Nice Atmosphere. Relaxing Leather couches. Good Micro Beer. Expect to pay real prices for real beer!

Great staff and atmosphere. Everyone is friendly and they always have something good on the TV's.

Love the people, Love the place... Good times... Can't wait for the NEW Game Room to get Open...

A great add on to the IG family with full bar, beer, wine, finger foods, and of course cigars.

Tessa is such an awesome bar tender, great atmosphere and wonderful service highly recommend!

Very nice laid back atmosphere, pool room is awesome. Carly the best bartender.

Great place to hang out, have a cigar and a drink and maybe a conversation.

Great place to have a good beer or four, and a cigar!!! My kind of people!

Decent cigar lounge limited cigar selection. Occasionally has live music.

The service is atrocious, every time I’ve been here it’s the same story.

Smokers delight. pool tables. Cheap happy hr drafts. ...SMOKEY …

Nice big bar. Live music, pool, And a beautiful Bartender. (Carly)

Great place. Weekly motorcycle ride starts here noon on Sunday's.

Sat for 10 minutes and never got waited on. Went somewhere else

Great atmosphere. Decent selection of cigars and beers

Nice cozy little spot for pool drinks and cigar

Great cigar bar with nice variety of smokes.

Great place to relax and enjoy a cigar!

Sheldon Aka Shawna made this beauty

You can get good cigars here.