This place was delicious and the service was great! An authentic Italian-American joint. I had the pizza alla vodka and a huge Long Island ice tea and enjoyed the chuck mangione music playing in the background. Prices were very reasonable for the portion size too. I’m still dreaming about returning. Go here, you won’t regret it. More

Went in to the new location for the first time & we were blown away. New place is beautiful. Was good to see familiar faces & as always the food was great. Best part of it, they let my 7 year old make her own pizza. That is an awesome touch. Going back very soon. My daughter can't wait to make her own pizza again.

By far the best pizza on Staten Island! Consistently. Our family has been coming here for years and it just seems to get better every time. Now we get a homemade brick oven bread as soon as you sit down? Yes please! Fresh ingredients, great brick oven taste, and phenomenal service. Can't wait until my next visit.

Amazing food!!! This pizzeria is next level and one of if not the best on Staten Island!! Our pizza was cooked perfectly and the crust was to die for! We had cheesecake for desert and it was delicious!! The service was incredible, huge shout out to Leila for her excellent service!! We will be returning!! More

The best service! The team goes above and beyond with their hospitality. The vodka pizza pie is perfect. The food is freshly made. Great place for groups. We had a team dinner here after the track meet at Ocean Breeze. It was not too crowded. There was no wait for 12 people on a Saturday late afternoon. More

There was some sort of problem honoring our 7 pm reservation. However, the owner was honest about the problem and was able to accommodate us with another table. We had to wait about 20 minutes longer. Putting that aside, we had an enjoyable experience. More

Goodfellas never disappoints. Had a round fresh mozzarella pie, Arugula salad with sliced apple, cranberries, goat cheese, and stuffed mushrooms. Food was presented beautifully. Everything was delicious! Reasonably priced Atomosphere

Great place, good food, bar is beautiful. Our waitress, Sophia, was fantastic. Scot, the owner, was very attentive and welcoming. Most notably, the entire staff from the bar tender to the bus attendants were all so friendly. Will definitely return.

The food here is absolutely delicious, and the pizza is among the best you will find anywhere on Staten Island. The environment and decor are perfect, and the staff are super friendly. The service was particularly quick (though not so quick

I happened to need parts for my bicycle and went to the Bike Shop. While there, I asked, where was a good place to eat? The technician just pointed his finger across the street at Goodfella’s. then he said he eats there all the time and the

Came in for my birthday dinner with 2 crazy hungry kids and the staff was amazing! They were patient & had our food out quickly. But what was even more amazing than the great staff was the food. Everything was delicious & I mean everything.

Anyone who thinks Goodfella's is just doing pizza is wrong! The pizza is fantastic, but my wife and I tried a wide array of items and they were all fantastic, from the pizza, to the porterhouse for 2 and the ravioli; every single thing was

We’re from VA and family lives on Long Island. Traffic was real bad and decided to get off to take a break and enjoy some food. Family got pizzas and I ordered the spaghetti and meatballs, just an original classic. It was delicious. I love

A very beautiful and chill atmosphere here! Two televisions line the bar area as well as two other dining areas ! One intimate area overlooking the bar and another larger dining area! The food here is exquisite and the presentation is also

The most amazing place the owner Andrew is hands on and caring. The manager Dana is great attentive, friendly and caring as well. This is just the atmosphere. Now let discuss the food. The food is delicious and the pizza not like any other

Delicious food and great ambiance. The service we obtained on the times we have visited have been nothing short of stellar. Servers were very polite and attentive. Both the food and drink menu has something for everyone. The sangria (red)

Came to Staten Island to take my fiance and her family to a baby shower, needed to kill a couple of hours and find a good place to eat. My father in law recommended Goodfella's, so we came here. Right off the bat, this place is beautiful,

When i went to eat here the other night the food and service was incredible. The pizza is the best i’ve ever had. The dough is always crispy and thick and it’s always cooked to perfection just like the rest of the food. Every time I go I

Amazing food and management! Because they take care of everyone so well and care about their employees from what I hear it is like a family and that is how I feel when I just go to eat or sit at the bar even. It is very welcoming and the

The food was delicious, from apps through dessert. The pizza, the pasta was all amazing! Must save room for the apple pie pizza alla mode. The service was top notch. Our server Lea was so friendly, so attentive and just the sweetest. The

I absolutely love Goodfella's and I'm so happy they moved a lot closer to where I live. I love how clean and kept the restaurant is inside. Amazing staff and owner! He always makes sure to check on us (we can clearly tell his customer's

Walked in Great Kills on this beautiful day to check out the new location of Goodfellas. The place is just lovely, with a pristine bar, loft VIP section and side with many tables facing the brick oven. The modern feel is very welcoming.

Truly the best pizza in the world, my favorite is the Clam Pie and a very close second would be the Vodka Pie. The funny thing is me and my family are going to be moving to this neighborhood and I was going to miss my local pizzeria in

Came in for lunch and I was not disappointed! I was told they are known for their vodka pie and it was delicious, a must have. We also started off with the fried calamari , which was good. It was light and tasty. This place has a quiet

I have tried many pizza places before, but this was by far the best one I've ever had. I visited them last Tuesday. Their Pizza alla Vodka was amazingly flavorful!! The sauce was amazing, the cheese perfect, the mushrooms added a nice

Had a vodka pie and some good drinks. The owner of the shop was just the nicest and extremely friendly. He thanked me for my service and it’s great knowing that this restaurant supports the vets here. Very nice inside as well!! More

We were a large party of 13 people and had an early reservation on a Saturday (5pm). When we arrived there was only one other table sat, so I thought we would be in and out relatively efficiently. That was not the case. By 6pm the

BEST CLAM PIE ON STATEN ISLAND! Not only was the food delicious, the staff was incredible. The owner specifically takes so much pride in this restaurant and is always making sure customers are satisfied. Definitely recommend! More

Clam pizza was dry and was not cut/divide properly since it was so dry, it was hard to cut them into a slice. Honey chicken sandwich was okay and the fries were soggy, the chicken was also dry. Overall not bad but not good either.

This is our first time at this location. (Been to the other location many times). Really like the new place. We were at the patio which was very nice. The food and drinks were excellent! Service was excellent as well. More

Always friendly staff and attentive service. One of our favorite places. Out of a number of places on SI that get high marks on social media for their pizza, Goodfellas ends up in the top of the list for us.

One of the best pizza places I've ever been too. Pizza was absolutely delicious. The crust was light and crispy and not bready. The smoked mozzerella was amazing. I can't recommend this place enough! More

Went. there With a friend, Nice quiet safe atmosphere had stuff mushrooms big clams and a strip stake that was absolutely delicious. Thank you Dana and Scott for a great night. Thumbs up for me

I loved the pizza and the bread here. The pizza crust was the best I've ever had and I had many. The service was just as good as the food. It a must try!!! Chicken Franchese was perfect. More

Goodfella's Margherita fresh mozzarella pie is so heavenly really good. Plus I go there in the afternoon to buy their loafs of italian bread drizzle with olive oil phenomenal. More

Best Pizza we have ever had! Food is amazing service was spot on! Attended their pizza school and I highly recommend! Scott and Andy were amazing! More

They have the best clam pie on Staten Island. No comparison. Slices are packed with fresh clams, ricotta, and cheese More

UPDATE: original review was approx. August. Ordered to give them a try again because there was a promo through the slice

Best Italian restaurant on the planet!! Every dish is delicious and desserts are phenomenal!!!
Servic…
More

Excellent food. Great price. We will definitely come back.
Food: 5…
More